P¨ç·Å®aÄ_«H ªþ¥ó1. ¤Ï¹ï®Ñ §Ç
¦¦bFAMV 1/2002¡A²×¼fªk°|º®u§õ°ê¯à´N©Úµ´ÄÀªk¡A¤S©e¬£ªº²×¼f°|¥qªk±`°È©x´£¥X¶Ç²¼¨Ã©e¬£ªº¤W¶D©eû·|¹ïÂƵø²×¼f°|±ø¨Ò½á¤©ì§i¤H¤W¶Dªº·íµMÅv¤O¡A¬O¥ú¤Ñ¤Æ¤é¤§¤Uªº¹Hªk¤Î½î½ñ¤HÅv¡A»´ä¤w¬Oµóª¾«Ñ»D¡A¤W¶D©eû·|ªº§P¨M¤S¼g¤£¥X²z¾Ú¡Aµý¹ê¤F»´ä²×¼fªk°|§P¨Mªº³¥ÆZ©Ê¡I ¦b FAMV 10/2006¡A§õ°ê¯à¥H¦P¼Ëªº¤â¬qé¹Üì§i¤H¤W¶Dªº·íµMÅv¤O¡A¦b¥ú¤Ñ¤Æ¤é¤§¤U¤S¤@¦¸½î½ñ¤HÅv¡I¦]¦¹³y´N¤F¥»³^¶Oªº¨Ó¦ÛCACV122/2004§P¨M®ÄÀ³¡I
CACV 122/2004 §P¨M¤S©~©ó J°ê¿³ ¨â¦¸ «§ï °ª°|³W«h²Ä40¸¹©R¥O²Ä1±ø³W«h¤å©ú³W©w ¼¹·´¤F»´äªk°| ¬d©ú¯u¬Û¥ú©ú¥¿¤jªº©ÛµP¡A°t¦X¾H°êºÕ¡B¥ôÅt§g¤ÎªL¤åÃvªk©x »z§P¡A¦p¤U´XÂI¨¬µý¦p¦¹¡G ¤@. ¾H°êºÕ¡B¥ôÅt§g¤ÎªL¤åÃvªk©xÀ´±o¦b®x¤W½è°Ý ³\°¶±j ¤j«ß®v¡G ¡§³\¤jª¬¡A§An±À½ÄÁ¦w¼wªº§P¨M¡A§A¦³¨S¦³´£¨ÑÃÒ¾ÚÃÒ©ú§Aªº³ø§i®Ñµ²½×«Y¨õ±o¶ì½¦¡H¡¨ ³\¤jª¬·í®x¤]µª±o²n¡G¡§ÉN¡¨¡I ¦ý¥L̪º§P¨M®Ñ¾Ì¤°»ò±À½ÄÁ¦w¼wªº§P¨M¡H ½Ð¬Ý¤W¶D®x³o»ò§@¥X ´Û¶B©Êªº§P¨Mªº¡G a. §P¨M®Ñ °²¤jªÅ¦a«üì§i¤HÁ|ÃÒ¤£¨¬¡A§P¨M®Ñ 40.(3)¡G ¡y ªk©x¤£¬Oì§i¤Hªº¥Nªí«ß®v¡A¤£¥i¯à¨ó§Uì§i¤H§¹¦¨¥L ªºÁ|ÃÒ³d¥ô¡A´£ÂI¥LÀ³ ¸Ó¦Vªk®x§e¥æ¬Æ»òÃÒ¾Ú¨ÓÀ±¸É¥LÃÒ¾Ú¤Wªº¤£¨¬¡A¦]¬°³o·|¹ï³Q§i¤Hºc¦¨¤£¤½¡F¡z b.
§P¨M®Ñ°²¤¯°²·N¦a¡§Ãö·Ó¡¨°_ì§i¤Hªº§Q¯q¡A¬Ý§P¨M®Ñ40.(6) ¡G ¡y²Ä¤@³Q§i¤H¸g¤w²M½L¡A¦Ó¥»®x¥çų©ó¤U¤å¤§²zµô©w²Ä¤G³Q§i¤Hªº¥æ¬Û¤W¶D¦¨ ¥\¡A«¶}ÃÒ¾Ú¥u·|¨Ïì§i¤H®ö¶O¤£¥²nªº®É¶¡¤Îª÷¿ú¡C¡z c.
¦ó¬°¡§¤U¤å¤§²z¡¨nµô©w¬ì§Þ¤¤¤ß¤W¶D¦¨¥\¡H §P¨M®Ñ62.«ü¡G ¡y¥»®x¦P·Nì§i¤H¦b¤µ¦¸ªº¼f°T¤¤¨S¦³´£¥X¨¬°÷¤Î¥i«H¿àªºÃÒ¾Ú¡A«üºÙ²Ä¤G ³Q§i¤H¦b§@¥X³ø§i¤W¤£²Å¦X±M·~¦X²z¤ô·Ç¤Î¦X²zÂÔ·Vµ{«×¤§³d¥ô¡C...¡z ¤G. ¤W¶D®x ¬O ¬G·N©¿²¤ ¼t®aªºÃÒ¾Ú¤w¨ã³Æ±M®aÃÒ¾Úªºªk«ß¦a¦ìªº¡A¨â¦ì³Q§i¤H¤S©Úµ´¶Ç¥l¥Lªº±M®aÃÒ¤H¥X®x¡AªLõ¥Á«K¬O°ß¤@ªº±M®aÃÒ¤H¡A ¹ï¨õø¥X¶ì½¦¬O¦³¹êª«ÃÒ¾Úªº¡A¨ì©³þ¤@°¦
ª¯²´ ¥i¥H¬Ý¨ì ¨â¦ì¤¸³Q§i¤H ¦³¦ó¤å¦r ¤Ï¹ï³Qì³^ªk®x½T»{ªö¯Ç¬°ªk®xÃÒ¾Ú¦@¦³1-23¶µ ÃÒ¾Ú¡H ì¼fªk®x®Ñ°O ¹H¤ß¦a¤£¥ú±m¦a¥u¦b¤å®Ñ¤¤½T»{ªö¯Ç¬°ªk®xÃÒ¾Ú¥u¦³4¶µ¡A¦ýì§i¤H¥Ó½ÐªºÁÃ¥»Åã¥Ü Áé¦w¼wªk©x©Ó»{¦³1-23¶µ¡A¤W¶D®x¥u¾Ìì¼fªk®x¹H³y¤å®ÑJ¾x§P¨M¡C ¥H¤Wªº¨Æ¹êºc¦¨¤F¦b»´äªºªk®x¡A¤@ÓÃþ¦ü¤T¦X·|¡B¶ÂªÀ·|ªº²Õ´¤w¦bªk©x°é§Î¦¨¡A¥L̹Hªk§P¨Mªº¥Øªº µL«D ¬O³z¹L¥»®×ªº«ß®v´£¥X¤F94¸Uªº³^¶O ¬°¦W¤À¨É§Q¯q¡A»´äªk°|ªk©x
©M ¶ÂªÀ·|¶°¹Î ªºÄd¸ô¥´§T ÁÙ¦³®t§O¶Ü¡H ¦]¦¹¡A»´ä¶ì½¦¬ì§Þ¤¤¤ß¦³¤½¥qªº¥Nªí«ß®v²zÀ³ª¾¹D ³Ó¤§¤£¤åŽÔ¬°¤w°] ªº¹D²z¡I ¦æ¬Fªø©x´¿½®Åv¤â´¤ªk©xªº¥ô©RÅv¡A »¤´bªk©x¹Hªk¡I ·í¾H°êºÕ¡B¥ôÅt§g¤ÎªL¤åÃvªk©x »z§P ªLõ¥Á ªñ¦Ê¸U³^¶O«á¡A¾H°êºÕ¥ß§Y´£¤É¬°¤W¶D®x°Æ®xªø¡AªL¤åÃv¥ß§Y´£¤É¬°¤g¦a¼fµô³B®xªø¥H¸ê¼úÀy¡I |